Spread a thin amount on some toasted pumpkin brioche (our #3 pick) or, for a real treat, swipe some onto a toasted bagel then top it off with Trader Joe’s pumpkin cream cheese (coming in at #2).

Trader Joe’s, good corporate citizen that it is, did NOT raise prices on any of the products we tried last year and again this year. Hold the Cone! (8 for $3.99): As one taster joked, “If it’s going ...